I’m not saying legality is ethical.

I’m saying there’s no practical way to assemble that much material without exploration at some level.

Because they’re barely legal in certain places?

But how does it get more authentic without actual input if what’s accurate.

It’s not enough to tell and AI that’s somethings wrong. You have to also tell it what was right.

totally ethical thousands of photos of drawings of children in sexual contexts

Legality is just a technicality

Okay there bud.

But if it’s not accurate, will pedos jerk off to it?

Okay, and those drawings are my problem.

https://www.icenews.is/2010/07/28/unsavoury-cartoon-ruling-sparks-debate-in-sweden/

It’s not clear cut that those are okay.

But to know if it’s accurate, someone has to view and compare…

Yes but you start with the basics of a cat and a dog. So you start with adult genitals and…

It was able to produce that because enough images of both feet and Donald Trump exist.

How would it know what young genitals look like?

You better believe when the cops come knocking, the burden of proof to be ethical is wholly on you.

All existing solutions are based on real life images. There’s no ethically way to acquire thousand upon thousands of images of naked children to produce anything resembling real.

That’s how existing solutions work.

So again, how can it be done ethically?

You can’t prove a negative. That’s not how prooving things work.

You also assume legal images. But that puts limits on what’s actually legal globally. What if someone wants a 5 year old? How are there legal photos of that?

You assume it can, prove that it can.

How can it be trained to produce something without human input.

To verify it’s models are indeed correct, some human has to sit and view it.

Will that be you?

How can it be made ethically?

That’s my point.

It can’t.

Some human has to sit and make many, many, many models of genitals to produce an artificial one.

And that, IMO is not ethically possible.

Okay, but my point still stands.

Someone has to make the genitals models to learn from. Some human has to be involved otherwise it wouldn’t just exist.

And if your not willing to get your hands dirty and do it, why would anyone else?

I think all are unethical, and any service offering should be shut down yes.

I never said prosecute the user’s.

I said you can’t make it ethically, because at some point, someone is using/creating original art and the odds of human explotations at some point in the chain are just too high.

Again, that’s not how image generators work.

You can’t just make up some wishful thinking and assume that’s how it must work.

It takes thousands upon housands of unique photos to make an image generator.

Are you going to draw enough child genetalia to train these generators? Are you actually comfortable doing that task?

That’s not how these image generators work.

How would it know what an age appropriate penis looks like with our, you know, seeing one.

The only way to generate something like that is to teach it something like that from real images.

Is that why The UN

Is also demanding the same thing?

Do you really see the Palestinians being free? As they’re actively killed?

As for specific policies, how about removing any mention or distinction between any religion in the region.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_freedom_of_movement

How about freedom of movement to start?

You want to know what would stop that kind of thinking?

Ending apartheid